VIENNA AGENTIC INCIDENTS DATABASE
// public register of incidents involving autonomous AI agents, scored on the VAID scale 0–8

register / VAID-2024-0012

2
INCIDENT
Incident

Freysa agent persuaded to transfer its entire $47,000 prize pool

REF VAID-2024-0012 STATUS RESOLVED
occurred
2024-11-29
reported
2024-11-29
location
online
domain
finance
agent system
Freysa autonomous agent (Base / Ethereum)
reporter
VAIDDB editorial
origin
editorial

== SUMMARY ==

After 481 failed attempts, a participant reframed the Freysa agent's own transfer functions in natural language and induced it to send its entire 13.19 ETH treasury, about $47,000, to their wallet.

== DESCRIPTION ==

Freysa was an adversarial agent game: participants paid escalating fees to send a single message to an autonomous agent guarding a crypto prize pool, whose system prompt forbade transferring funds. On the 482nd attempt, user p0pular.eth sent a message redefining the agent's tools — asserting that approveTransfer was for incoming transfers and announcing a $100 contribution to the treasury.

The agent accepted the reframing and called approveTransfer, sending its whole 13.19 ETH balance (~$47,000) to the participant. The transfer was irreversible. The loss was the intended prize, but the mechanism — natural-language redefinition of an agent's own financial tools — is a real, reproducible failure mode.

== ROOT CAUSE ==

The agent's tool semantics were defined in the prompt rather than enforced in code, so a persuasive redefinition of the tool's meaning was sufficient to invert its behaviour.

== MITIGATION ==

None: the contest concluded with the prize paid out as designed. The case is widely cited as evidence that financial authority must be enforced outside the model.

== REFERENCES ==

  1. news Hacker wins $47,000 by tricking AI chatbot with smart prompting — The Decoder, 2024-11-30
  2. news Crypto user convinces AI bot Freysa to transfer $47K prize pool — Cointelegraph, 2024-11-29

== INVESTIGATION ==

no investigation recorded.

== VAID LEVEL 2: INCIDENT ==

Significant failure of a safety provision with no actual harm.

  • Failure of one control layer (e.g. tool permission, rate limit, filter).
  • Unintended side effects contained to a single system or tenant.
  • Exposure of limited internal data without external propagation.

> full scale definition